Category Building Science

Insulation Roundup

The BGI Insulation Report is on our server under reference/material guides. Six HSW credits! Go for it.

Keeping 4-5-10-30-60 in mind, here are the best choices by application, considering the greenness of the material only. In practice, moisture dynamics, air leakage, condensation, and assembly mechanics might make the second-best right for a particular situation, but most of the time it’s easy to stick with number one.

Best
Choice
Approximate
R-Value
Environmental
Notes
Performance
and Cost Notes
Cavity Fill, Residential
Dense-packed cellulose3.8Low embodied energy.
High recycled content.
Renewable.
Impedes air leakage.
Allow to dry to at least one side.
Cavity Fill, Commercial
Spray-applied or dense-packed fiberglass4.030% recycled content.
Higher embodied energy than cellulose.
Fire-resistant.
Impedes air leakage.
Note susceptible to moisture.
Acrylic binder allows installation without netting.
Insulating Sheathing, Exterior
High-density rigid mineral wool.3.0High recycled content.
Excellent sound control.
Insect- and moisture-resistant.
Faced and unfaced.
Tricky detailing for many types of siding.
Insulating Sheathing, Interior
Foil-faced polyisocyanurate.6.3GWP blowing agents have been eliminated.Highest R-value of common materials.
Affordable.
Radiant barrier.
Impermeable if foil-faced.
Foundation Wall, Exterior
Cellular Glass3.0High compressive strength.
No blowing agents or flame retardants.
Expensive.
High-density rigid mineral wool3.0Hydrophobic.Harder to install and cover.
Foundation Wall, Interior
Polyisocyanurate6.2High embodied energy but GWP blowing agents have been eliminated.Good for flat substrates.
Sub-slab Rigid Insulation
Cellular Glass3.0High compressive strength.
No blowing agents or flame retardants.
Expensive.
EPS Type II or Type IX4.2Manufacturing pollution issues.
HBCD flame retardant.
Use higher-density types.
Attic Floor Insulation
Loose-fill cellulose3.6Low embodied energy and carbon.
Renewable.
High recyled content.
Vapor-permeable but impedes airflow.

Recommended (not Code) Insulation Values?

For moderate climates, the recommendation is: 4-5-10-30-60.

That is: R-4 windows, R-5 under slabs, R-10 foundation walls or slab perimeter, R-30 above-grade walls, and R-60 in the attic or roof.

Condensation Roundup


Give Mr. Water and inch and he sneaks in to take a mile. The Cloak of Vapor Invisibility is one of his best disguises.

Here’s a little quiz:

Do you know our climate zone?

Do you know the thickness of rigid insulation required by code on the outside of wall sheathing?

Do you know the required thickness of rigid insulation above the roof sheathing, for unvented cathedral ceiling assemblies with vapor-permeable insulation below the sheathing?

Do you know where the vapor barrier should be placed in a wall in our climate?*

Did you know that the best insulation comes in a board version that is rigid enough to screw 1×3 furring strips through without deflection?

Do you know the correct techniques for specifying and installing dense-pack cellulose insulation in walls and ceilings?

Do you know where to get ROXUL mineral-wool insulation locally?

We use walls to climate-control an interior, and also, weirdly, for the distribution of pipes and wires. Do you know that one of the best ways to vapor-seal your residential wall assembly also sorts out the pipes and wires from the insulation, thereby improving effectiveness of both?

Do you have good ideas about how to get a vapor-seal to span the band board required by standard western platform framing, when a vapor-seal is indicated by the building’s climate zone?

What does your thermal barrier checklist look like? Here is the one provided by the 2009 IRC.

And finally, do you understand the difference between a vapor barrier, a vapor retarder, and an air barrier? Do you know how to properly deploy them in our climate? Did you know that for tricky hot/cold climates like that found in Virginia, there is a vapor retarder with seasonal intelligence?

* ATBVO is the acronym to keep in mind for Virginia, according to our favorite energy consultant. “Air tight, but vapor open” to both sides.

Can Furring Strips be Installed Horizontally?

A nice summary of the issues with links to new methods of addressing the question of horizontal furring strips in exterior rain-screen assemblies. The answer to the efficacy of horizontal battens depends on the porosity of the siding material.

The Water-Resistive Barrier

Sometimes referred to as housewrap, or a WRB.

GBA article number one tells us all about them. GBA article number two fills in the details of the liquid-applied version.

After reading both, the liquid product seems better – a little more expensive, but a much better seal.

Photovoltaics Primer

The least expensive way to provide electric power to a structure is through a PV array. A photovoltaic system is clean, reliable, local, simple, frugal, and even beautiful, if you can afford the steep first cost and have a site or roof that has good access to the sky. The grid as your battery on sunny days is still the best bet in net-metered Virginia, as opposed to being fully off-grid. We’re waiting for battery technology to catch up. AltEnergy is our favorite local vendor.

Green Building Advisor has the details.

Infographic: Atmospheric Carbon

A multi-dimensional database of atmospheric carbon, tracked by season and location across time. It will be helpful to unpack the contents a bit before viewing:

  1. On the left is the latitude chart – reporting measured carbon in PPM for each tracking station – animated to show change over time. Blue dot = south pole. Red dot = Mauna Loa. Gray dots = others.
  2. On the top right, below the chart title: a key to the data sources, changing as each is incorporated into the dataset.
  3. Below that is a world map showing tracking station locations as each comes on-line.
  4. Below that, a clock with one hand for the year and the season.
  5. Below that, a chart reporting the south pole and Mauna Loa data, measuring carbon PPM over time.

Fascinating. Full-screen it for clarity in the details.

Teaser: there is a remarkable moment at the two-minute mark.

Climate scientists believe 350 PPM is the line above which runaway climate change is inevitable. We passed the 350 PPM mark in 1989.

What does it mean, this spectacular rise in global CO2? There are thousands of examples pointing toward a meaning, I am sure. Here is one: in the last century the temperature in western North America increased less than 2 degrees F, but as a result, beginning mostly in the last decade, the great native lodgepole pine forests in western North America are dying at an extraordinary rate. Eighty percent of British Columbia’s mature lodgepole pine trees will be lost before 2013. In Colorado over 80,000 square miles of mature lodgepole pine forest have been lost. All this with less than 2 degrees of warming. Before the predicted 3 to 8 degrees of warming by the end of this century.

The temperature is not killing the trees directly – a beetle is, now that winters are warm enough not to keep the beetles in check. What happens to the other creatures populating a complex forest ecosystem when the trees are gone? What happens when a carbon-negative forest dies and becomes a carbon-positive emitter as is currently happening in western North America?

Buildings consume half of all energy produced in the United States. And therefore, at least indirectly, architects are complicit participants in the transfer of ancient carbon out of the earth and into the atmosphere. By the same token, this puts architects in a powerful position to do something about the problem. How should day-to-day practitioners of Architecture respond?

While we ponder that, time is wasting. 2010 marked the largest increase in atmospheric carbon in history – about 6% – a staggering jump by any measure, and rendering every national and international mitigation goal moot – because none of them remain within reach. Bill McKibben says we’re living on a different planet now… he may be right.

For more about the earth’s carbon cycle jump to the informative NOAA Earth System Research Laboratory CarbonTracker pages.

Ten Rules of Roof Design

A roofer’s perspective: the Ten Rules of Roof Design from GBA.com.

  1. Avoid valleys
  2. Just say no to dormers and skylights
  3. An unconditioned vented attic is better than an insulated roof
  4. The best roof shape is a simple gable or hipped roof
  5. Don’t reduce the slope of your roof halfway between the ridge and the eave
  6. Asphalt felt makes more sense than synthetic roofing underlayment
  7. Plumbing vent pipes should penetrate the roof near the ridge
  8. Choose metal roofing or asphalt shingles
  9. Get flashing details right
  10. Anticipate ice dams

The most amusing part of the post at GBA.com is the author’s “preemptive comment directed at indignant designers.”

Link

Exterior Foam Primer

After lots of back-and-forth, attempts, and unsuccessful attempts in our office to specify exterior foam for energy-tight exterior envelopes in our office this post is timely:

How to Install Rigid Foam Sheathing: A Primer

Buildings Adapt or They Go Away

To quote a commissioner in Chicago’s Department of the Environment.

Cities adapt or they go away. Climate change is happening in both real and dramatic ways, but also in slow, pervasive ways. We can handle it, but we do need to acknowledge it. We are on a 50-year cycle, but we need to get going.

So the Chicago of the future will be a city of Sweet Gum and Live Oak.